The Work, Torah Teaching and Legacy of Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi (the "Chacham Tzvi"): A Comprehensive Study
23 min read4,508 words
His Life, the Upheavals of His Era and the Historical Background
Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch ben Yaakov Ashkenazi, known in the world of Torah and halakha as the "Chacham Tzvi" after his book of responsa, was one of the greatest halakhic decisors and spiritual leaders at the turn of the 17th and 18th centuries [cite: 1, 2, 3]. The course of his life and his wanderings clearly reflect the turbulent geopolitical and demographic reality of the Jewry of Europe and of the Ottoman Empire in the early modern period [cite: 1, 3, 4, 5]. This era was marked by deep upheavals in the wake of the Sabbatean crisis, by the movement of communities between different cultural centers, and by the rise of new centers of halakhic authority bridging East and West [cite: 1, 3, 4, 5].
The Chacham Tzvi was born on Sunday, 1 Elul 5418 (1658), in the town of Trebitsch (Třebíč) in the region of Moravia, in the Crown of Bohemia [cite: 2]. He grew up within a family of exalted rabbinic lineage: his father, Rabbi Yaakov Zak Ashkenazi, was one of the outstanding Torah scholars of his generation and served as the teacher of Rabbi David Oppenheim [cite: 1, 2]. His mother, Nechama, was the daughter of the gaon Rabbi Ephraim ben Yaakov HaKohen, author of the responsa work "Sha'ar Ephraim", who was a descendant of the chief rabbi of Jerusalem, Rabbi Ephraim Fish, and the son-in-law of the son-in-law of Rabbi Eliyahu Baal Shem of Chelm [cite: 1, 2, 3]. In his childhood the family moved to the city of Alt-Ofen (Ofen / Buda, today part of Budapest), where his grandfather served as rabbi of the community, and from him and from his father he received his early Torah learning [cite: 1, 2, 5].
In 5433 (1673), when he was about fifteen, the Chacham Tzvi was sent to Salonica in the Ottoman Balkans [cite: 1, 2, 4, 5]. Salonica was at that time a unique Torah and Sephardic center, and for about two years he devoted himself to study there in the beit midrash of the gaon Rabbi Eliyahu Covo [cite: 1, 2, 5]. During his stay there he deeply internalized the Sephardic methodology of study, observed at close range the influence of the Sabbatean movement in the Balkans, and was even ordained by the great beit din of Constantinople with the title "Chacham" before he had reached the age of eighteen [cite: 1, 2, 3, 5]. He then came to Istanbul, where he gained renown as an exceptional prodigy and acquired a title of honor that was exceptional for a young scholar of Ashkenazi origin [cite: 3, 5].
In 5436 (1676) he returned to Ofen, married and established his first home [cite: 2, 5]. The tranquility of his life, however, was cut short by a grave tragedy in 5446 (1686), during the siege that the Austrian army laid on the city of Ofen in order to liberate it from the Turks [cite: 1, 2, 5]. An artillery shell struck his house directly, brought it down, and caused the immediate death of his wife and his only daughter [cite: 1, 2, 5]. The Chacham Tzvi escaped from the ruined city and fled for his life to Bosnia, where he was appointed to serve as rabbi and "Chacham" of the community of Sarajevo until 1689 [cite: 1, 2, 5, 6]. He later set out on a journey of wandering through Europe with the aim of ransoming his parents, who had been taken captive in the war and were ransomed in Berlin, and on his way he passed through Venice, where he was a guest in the home of Rabbi Shmuel Aboab [cite: 2].
The next major station in his life was in northern Germany, in the city of Altona [cite: 1, 2]. There he married for a second time, to Sarah Rivka, the daughter of Rabbi Meshullam Zalman Mirels Neumark, av beit din (head of the rabbinic court) of the communities of Altona, Hamburg and Wandsbek (AHU) [cite: 1, 2, 7]. The Chacham Tzvi lived in Altona for eighteen years, founded an important beit midrash and yeshiva, devoted himself to disseminating Torah and enacted public ordinances [cite: 1, 2, 8]. In 5466 (1706), after the death of his father-in-law, he was appointed av beit din of the AHU communities under an arrangement of half-yearly rotation alongside Rabbi Moshe ben Mordechai Ziskind Rothenburg [cite: 1, 2]. In 5469 (1709), however, a sharp halakhic dispute broke out between them concerning a chicken in which no heart was found [cite: 1, 2]. The Chacham Tzvi ruled it kosher, whereas his colleague declared it treif [cite: 1]. Following the public rift that became entrenched in the community, the Chacham Tzvi preferred to resign from his post as the local rabbinic authority and to concentrate on leading his yeshiva [cite: 1, 2].
In 5469 (1710) he accepted the offer of the Ashkenazi community of Amsterdam to serve as its chief rabbi [cite: 1, 2, 3]. The community allotted him an enormous salary of 2,500 Dutch guilders a year, a sum unprecedented at that time [cite: 2, 3]. In Amsterdam, in 5472 (1712), he printed his renowned book, the responsa "Chacham Tzvi" [cite: 1, 2, 3]. Despite his exalted standing, he refused to accept monetary payments for adjudicating Torah cases, in order to preserve complete independence vis-à-vis the lay leaders of the community [cite: 3].
His tenure in Amsterdam came to its stormy end following the arrival of the Sabbatean preacher Nehemiah Hiya Hayon [cite: 1, 3]. The Chacham Tzvi, together with Rabbi Moshe Hagiz, declared all-out war on Hayon and placed him under a ban [cite: 1, 2]. This step provoked a head-on confrontation with the leadership of the Portuguese-Sephardic community of Amsterdam, headed by Rabbi Shlomo Ayllon, which saw it as an encroachment on and an infringement of its authority [cite: 2, 3]. The dispute spilled over into the courts of the civil authorities, and in 5474 (1714), out of a desire to prevent a desecration of God's name, the Chacham Tzvi left Amsterdam [cite: 1, 2, 3]. He wandered to England, where he was received with great honor by the Portuguese community of London [cite: 2, 3, 7], and from there he moved to Poland and Galicia [cite: 4, 9]. At the end of his days he was appointed av beit din of the city of Lvov, but he served in his post for only a few months until his death on 1 Iyar 5478 (3 May 1718), at the age of about fifty-eight [cite: 1, 2, 3].
| Biographical station | Approximate dates | Communal role and standing | Key events and environmental influence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trebitsch and Ofen | 1658–1673 | Student; grandson of the av beit din of Ofen | Torah study under his father and grandfather (author of "Sha'ar Ephraim") [cite: 1, 2, 5] |
| Salonica and Istanbul | 1673–1676 | Student-colleague; ordained as "Chacham" | Acquisition of the Sephardic method of study under Rabbi Eliyahu Covo [cite: 1, 2, 5] |
| Sarajevo | 1686–1689 | "Chacham" and rabbi of the community | Spiritual leadership following the loss of his family in the siege of Ofen [cite: 1, 2, 5, 6] |
| Altona (AHU) | 1689–1710 | Rosh yeshiva; av beit din in rotation | Founding of a yeshiva; printing of the Taz with his glosses; the "chicken without a heart" controversy [cite: 1, 2, 8] |
| Amsterdam | 1710–1714 | Av beit din of the Ashkenazi community | Printing of the responsa "Chacham Tzvi"; the struggle against Nehemiah Hiya Hayon [cite: 1, 2, 3] |
| London, Poland and Lvov | 1714–1718 | Visiting rabbi in London; av beit din of Lvov | Setting matters right in the London community; his death in Lvov [cite: 1, 2, 3, 9, 10] |
His Principal Teachers and the Fusion of the Ashkenazi and Sephardic Methods of Study
The intellectual and halakhic development of the Chacham Tzvi was founded on a unique and rare fusion of two central traditions of study in the Jewish world, which in his time were to a large extent cut off from each other: the analytical Ashkenazi tradition of Central and Eastern Europe, and the textual Sephardic tradition of the sages of the Balkans and the Ottoman Empire [cite: 1, 2, 5].
The principal teachers of the Chacham Tzvi shaped the two wings of his Torah personality [cite: 1, 2, 5]. His father, Rabbi Yaakov Zak Ashkenazi, bequeathed to him sharpness of intellect, comprehensive mastery of the sources of the Talmud and the early decisors, and the profundity characteristic of the sages of Ashkenaz [cite: 1, 2, 5]. His maternal grandfather, the gaon Rabbi Ephraim ben Yaakov HaKohen (author of "Sha'ar Ephraim"), gave him an orderly halakhic methodology, based on lucid analysis of the responsa of the Geonim and the Rishonim while exercising extreme caution in grave matters such as the release of agunot [cite: 1, 2, 11]. On the other hand, his stay in Salonica in the beit midrash of the gaon Rabbi Eliyahu Covo exposed him to the Sephardic method of study [cite: 1, 2, 5]. Under the guidance of Rabbi Eliyahu Covo the Chacham Tzvi adopted linguistic precision, the pursuit of a straightforward conceptual understanding of the words of Maimonides (Rambam) and the Rif, and distance from convoluted pilpul that does not withstand the test of the plain meaning [cite: 1, 2, 5].
This methodological fusion produced in the Chacham Tzvi an original way of learning [cite: 2]. Whereas Ashkenazi scholars of his time often tended toward sharp pilpul and the construction of complex doctrinaire lines of reasoning, the Chacham Tzvi combined Ashkenazi sharpness with Sephardic clarity of formulation and philological integrity [cite: 1, 2, 3, 5]. The intellectual flexibility he acquired enabled him to rule naturally for Ashkenazi and Sephardic communities alike, and to be perceived by members of both communities as an independent supreme authority [cite: 1, 4, 5, 12]. His receiving the title "Chacham" and holding it alongside his family name "Ashkenazi" became a clear expression of this bridging between parallel halakhic worlds [cite: 1, 5].
His Literary and Cultural Oeuvre
The Torah oeuvre of the Chacham Tzvi, although not comprising many volumes, is characterized by analytical density and a quality of ruling that have given it foundational standing in the Jewish bookshelf [cite: 1, 2].
His central and best-known work is the book of responsa "Chacham Tzvi", first published in Amsterdam in 5472 (1712) [cite: 1, 2, 3]. In its expanded editions the book contains 158 sections, and it gathers questions and answers addressed to him from all over the Diaspora – from Germany, Poland, Holland, England, Italy and the cities of the Ottoman Empire [cite: 12, 13]. His responsa are characterized by great concision, structural clarity and an uncompromising pursuit of a decision based on the plain meaning of the sugya [cite: 3]. This book combines profound Talmudic novellae with practical rulings, and immediately upon its printing it was accepted as an enduring asset in the world of halakhic instruction [cite: 1, 2].
Apart from his central book, the Chacham Tzvi made a decisive contribution to the dissemination and interpretation of earlier foundational works [cite: 1, 14]. In 5452 (1692), during his stay in Altona, he printed for the first time the work of Rabbi David HaLevi Segal (the Taz) on Shulchan Arukh Yoreh De'ah, and appended to it his own incisive glosses and explanations, a step that made his name known throughout Europe [cite: 1]. He also composed comprehensive glosses on the four parts of the Tur and the Shulchan Arukh, as well as glosses and explanations on the Babylonian Talmud [cite: 14]. His glosses were widely incorporated into the writings of later decisors, among them the "Magen Avraham", the "Be'er Heitev", the "Mishnah Berurah" and the writings of Rabbi Akiva Eiger [cite: 15, 16].
| Title of the work | Year / place of printing | Nature and methodology of the work | Influence and standing in the Jewish bookshelf |
|---|---|---|---|
| Responsa Chacham Tzvi | 5472 (1712), Amsterdam | Responsa and novellae on sugyot from all the Diaspora communities of Israel [cite: 1, 3, 12] | A masterpiece of lucid ruling, pursuit of the plain meaning and rejection of pilpul [cite: 3] |
| Glosses on the Taz (Yoreh De'ah) | 5452 (1692), Altona | Explanations and critical notes on the Turei Zahav commentary [cite: 1] | Establishment of his standing as the leading scholar of the generation and dissemination of the Taz commentary in Europe [cite: 1] |
| Glosses on the Shulchan Arukh and the Shas | Incorporated in later editions | Textual glosses, emendations of readings and explanations of sugyot [cite: 14, 15, 16] | A permanent presence among the commentaries of the Shulchan Arukh and the Shas [cite: 15, 16] |
His Halakhic Method, Fundamental Principles and Halakhic-Philosophical Affairs
The halakhic teaching of the Chacham Tzvi rests on three guiding principles: the subordination of ruling to the laws of nature and reality, complete judicial independence without fear of the powerful, and an uncompromising struggle against ideological and dogmatic deviation [cite: 1, 3, 17].
Scientific Realism in Ruling: The "Chicken Without a Heart" Controversy
The Chacham Tzvi championed the view that the laws of halakha do not contradict the laws of physiology and nature that the Creator implanted in the world [cite: 17]. This view stood at the center of the famous dispute in AHU (1709) concerning a slaughtered chicken in which no trace of a heart was found [cite: 1]. Whereas Rabbi Moshe Ziskind Rothenburg declared the chicken treif out of concern that it involved a rare defect rendering it treifa, the Chacham Tzvi ruled categorically that the chicken was entirely kosher [cite: 1]. His reasoning was based on a physiological axiom: no animal with a blood system can live even a single moment without a heart [cite: 1]. Accordingly, he determined that the heart had certainly existed during its lifetime and had been dislodged or eaten by a cat when the innards were opened [cite: 1]. His willingness to rely on the known laws of nature against halakhic anxieties brought out his realist positions [cite: 1, 17].
Renowned Halakhic-Philosophical Responsa
The ruling in the matter of Rabbi David Nieto and the concept of "nature" (section 18): In 5465 (1705) the Portuguese community in London was in turmoil following a sermon by Chacham Rabbi David Nieto, in which he argued that nature and divine providence are one and the same [cite: 10, 17, 18]. His opponents accused him of Spinozism and heresy [cite: 10, 18]. The matter was brought before the Chacham Tzvi for decision [cite: 18]. In a brilliant responsum he prevented a severe schism and cleared Nieto of all guilt [cite: 10, 18]. Relying on the commentary of Rabbi Yehuda Moscato on the book "Kuzari" (first discourse, sections 15–16), the Chacham Tzvi explained that the Holy One, blessed be He, is called "nature" (teva) in the sense that He "stamps (tove'a) with His seal the nature of all creatures", and clarified that speaking of nature in general is nothing but an expression of continuous divine providence [cite: 17, 18].
The halakhic status of a golem for a minyan (section 93): In a pioneering theoretical responsum, the Chacham Tzvi discussed the question whether a golem created by means of combinations of letters from Sefer Yetzirah (as is attributed to his forebear, Rabbi Eliyahu Baal Shem of Chelm) may be counted among the ten of a prayer quorum [cite: 19]. The Chacham Tzvi determined unequivocally that the golem is not counted in a minyan [cite: 19]. His legal reasoning was that only one who is obligated in the commandments and possesses a moral human soul is defined as a "man" or as "his fellow" with respect to the obligations of sanctity [cite: 19].
Extreme caution in the laws of agunot: The Chacham Tzvi was known as very stringent and meticulous in the laws of releasing agunot [cite: 11]. This conduct drew on a traumatic event in his family: his father, Rabbi Yaakov, was taken captive by Tatars and was presumed dead, and while a friend of his testified to his death and his wife was about to remarry, the father managed to escape from captivity and appeared at the last moment [cite: 11]. The event instilled in the Chacham Tzvi extra caution in examining halakhic testimony [cite: 11].
The Struggle Against Sabbateanism: The Affair of Nehemiah Hiya Hayon
The experience of the Chacham Tzvi in Salonica and in Bosnia brought him into close contact with the hidden destructiveness of the Sabbatean movement [cite: 1, 3, 5]. When Nehemiah Hiya Hayon arrived in Amsterdam and spread his theological books, the Chacham Tzvi immediately identified the disguised Sabbatean citations in the book "Oz le-Elohim" [cite: 1, 3]. Together with Rabbi Moshe Hagiz he launched an open campaign, placed Hayon under a ban and denounced his writings [cite: 1, 2]. The struggle escalated into a severe confrontation with the head of the Portuguese community, Rabbi Shlomo Ayllon, who backed Hayon [cite: 2, 3]. The Chacham Tzvi refused to retreat from his positions or to compromise with the community leadership, and was prepared to pay the heavy personal price of losing his exalted post and being driven from the city, so long as he did not grant legitimacy to Sabbateanism [cite: 1, 2, 3].
| Issue / controversy | Place and time | Position of the Chacham Tzvi | Methodological and intellectual significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken without a heart | Altona, 5469 (1709) | Kosher; a living animal without a heart is not a possible reality [cite: 1] | Subordination of ruling to the laws of physiology and nature [cite: 1, 17] |
| The sermon of Rabbi David Nieto | London, 5465 (1705) | Full acquittal; "nature" is the manifestation of providence (the Kuzari) [cite: 17, 18] | Distinction between Spinozist pantheism and continuous divine providence [cite: 10, 17] |
| A golem for a minyan | Responsa Chacham Tzvi, section 93 | Not counted; it lacks a soul and moral responsibility [cite: 19] | Definition of "a human being" and "obligation in the commandments" on the legal plane [cite: 19] |
| The Nehemiah Hayon controversy | Amsterdam, 5473 (1713) | Absolute ban on Hayon and his Sabbatean books [cite: 1, 2] | Willingness to pay a heavy personal price in the war against heresy [cite: 1, 3, 5] |
His Students, His Institutions and His Influence on the World of the Yeshivot
During the years of his tenure in Altona and in Amsterdam, the Chacham Tzvi headed central yeshivot and raised hundreds of students who spread his Torah throughout Europe [cite: 1, 2, 8]. His yeshiva in Altona attracted outstanding scholars, and he invested great effort in imparting the straightforward and critical method of analysis [cite: 1, 2, 8].
Among his prominent students and those influenced by his method was Rabbi David Fraenkel, author of the enduring commentary "Korban ha-Edah" on the Jerusalem Talmud [cite: 20]. Rabbi David Fraenkel adopted his teacher's approach of pursuing the plain meaning of texts and precise verbal analysis, an approach that was essential for deciphering the obscure texts of the Yerushalmi [cite: 20].
Alongside guiding his principal students toward the rabbinate, the Chacham Tzvi devoted much attention to public ordinances and to strengthening study among householders and working people [cite: 8]. In Altona he enacted a permanent ordinance for public study of Mishnah in the synagogues before the evening prayer, an ordinance that later spread to many communities in Europe and shaped communal life [cite: 8].
The Line of His Descendants and His Legacy for Generations
The legacy of the Chacham Tzvi continued to pulse with great force not only through his works but also through his illustrious line of descendants, who led the world of Torah, halakhic ruling and Hasidism in the 18th and 19th centuries [cite: 1, 2, 9].
His marriage to Sarah Rivka produced sixteen children [cite: 2, 9]. His most famous son is Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), one of the greatest sages of the 18th century [cite: 1, 2, 14]. The Yaavetz inherited from his father uncompromising rabbinic independence (as he expressed in his resignation from the rabbinate of Emden and in his saying that he used to recite the blessing "who has not made me an av beit din") [cite: 14], broad scientific and Talmudic erudition, and zeal for the purity of faith against the Sabbatean crisis [cite: 14]. The Yaavetz vigorously continued his father's campaign, leading the famous controversy against Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschütz and his amulets [cite: 14]. In his autobiographical books "Megillat Sefer" and "Torat ha-Kenaot" the Yaavetz preserved the memory of his father and documented the course of his life in detail [cite: 2, 14].
Other descendants of the Chacham Tzvi served as heads of kloyzn and as heads of central rabbinic courts, and through them strong communal branches extended [cite: 2, 9]:
Rabbi Natan Ashkenazi of Brody: one of the rabbis of the kloyz in Brody [cite: 2, 9]. From his direct descendants, son after son, came Rabbi Yaakov Lorberbaum of Lissa (author of "Netivot ha-Mishpat" and "Chavat Da'at") and Rabbi Mordechai Benet (rabbi of Moravia) [cite: 2, 9].
Rabbi David Ashkenazi (av beit din of Yaritchev): grandfather of Rabbi David of Tarnogrod, who was the grandfather of the gaon Rabbi Chaim Halberstam of Sanz (author of "Divrei Chaim" and founder of Sanz Hasidism) [cite: 2, 9].
- Rabbi Ephraim Ashkenazi: one of the rabbis of the kloyz in Brody and of the sages of Lvov, whose daughter married his elder brother, the Yaavetz [cite: 2, 9].
- Rabbi Avraham Meshullam Zalman: served as rabbi in Ostroh and in London [cite: 2, 9].
- His daughters: married outstanding Torah scholars, among them Miriam, who married Rabbi Aryeh Leib (av beit din of Amsterdam, grandson of Rabbi Heschel of Lublin), and Rachel, who married Rabbi Yitzchak (av beit din of Nesvizh, son of Rabbi Meir Eisenstadt) [cite: 2, 9].
In the world of Hasidism a special reverence was maintained for the lineage of the Chacham Tzvi, and the Baal Shem Tov remarked that the family of the Chacham Tzvi is one of the most distinguished and pure families in Israel from generation to generation [cite: 7].
| Name of descendant / family branch | Role and center of activity | Prominent figures among the descendants | Torah and historical contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz) | Altona and Emden [cite: 14] | The Yaavetz himself [cite: 1, 2, 14] | War against Sabbateanism, the responsa "She'ilat Yaakov", the Siddur Beit Yaakov [cite: 14] |
| Rabbi Natan Ashkenazi of Brody | The kloyz in Brody [cite: 2, 9] | Rabbi Yaakov of Lissa, Rabbi Mordechai Benet [cite: 2, 9] | Foundational works in halakha ("Netivot ha-Mishpat", "Chavat Da'at") [cite: 2, 9] |
| Rabbi David Ashkenazi of Yaritchev | Av beit din of Yaritchev [cite: 2, 9] | Rabbi Chaim Halberstam of Sanz [cite: 2, 9] | Founding of the Sanz Hasidic dynasty and the book "Divrei Chaim" [cite: 2, 9] |
| Miriam (wife of Rabbi Aryeh Leib) | Amsterdam [cite: 2, 9] | Rabbis of Amsterdam and its environs [cite: 2, 9] | Rabbinic leadership in Western Europe [cite: 2, 9] |
Summary and Conclusions
The life, work and Torah teaching of Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi, the Chacham Tzvi, constitute a cornerstone in the development of halakha and of rabbinic leadership in the transition to the modern era [cite: 1, 2, 3, 5]. An analysis of the whole body of data on his life and work yields central conclusions:
- 1.A methodological and geographical bridge: The Chacham Tzvi achieved a rare synthesis between the Sephardic method of analysis and Ashkenazi sharpness [cite: 1, 2, 5]. This fusion enabled him to act as a supreme halakhic authority accepted by all the communities of Israel, and to lead central communities in the Balkans, Germany, Holland, England and Poland [cite: 1, 3, 4, 5, 12].
- 2.Realist ruling and spiritual independence: His halakhic teaching placed at its center the pursuit of the plain meaning, subordination to the laws of nature and reality, and the rejection of idle pilpul [cite: 1, 3, 17]. His judicial independence was expressed in his willingness to give up exalted posts and financial comfort so as not to subject his rulings to the dictates of lay leaders [cite: 3].
- 3.A firm stand against Sabbateanism: His uncompromising struggle against Nehemiah Hiya Hayon and the Sabbatean elements in Amsterdam served as a critical barrier to the spread of Sabbatean heresy in Europe [cite: 1, 2, 3]. His willingness to endure wandering and damage to his standing for the sake of the purity of faith fixed his image as a model of zealous and uncompromising halakhic leadership [cite: 1, 3, 5].
- 4.A seal for generations: The influence of the Chacham Tzvi continues to endure in the Torah world to this day [cite: 1, 2]. His book of responsa serves as a foundational layer in every halakhic discussion [cite: 1, 2], while his direct descendants – among them his son the Yaavetz, the author of the "Netivot", the "Divrei Chaim" of Sanz and Rabbi Mordechai Benet – led the world of halakha, commentary and Hasidism and ensured the central presence of his legacy for generations [cite: 2, 9, 14].
Sources20
- 1.רבי צבי הירש אשכנזי מלבוב זצ”ל (“חכם צבי”) - ערוץ התורה, daily-torah.tv/רבי-צבי-הירש-אשכנזי-מלבוב-זצל-חכם-צבי/
- 2.צבי הירש אשכנזי - ויקיפדיה, he.wikipedia.org/wiki/צבי_הירש_אשכנזי
- 3.Tzvi Ashkenazi - Wikipedia, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tzvi_Ashkenazi
- 4.לפתע שוב החל הרעש המטריד מעליית הגג, הזמזום המעצבן שמזה תקופה ארוכה מורט את עצביו של בעל-הבית שוחר השקט והסדר. הפעם פקעה סבלנותו - הוא קם מכסאו, ונטל מטאטא זרדים ענק שעמד בפינת החדר... - דרשו, dirshu.co.il/דע-יקירי-כי-רציתי-לברכך-גם-בדורות-ישרים/
- 5.COL מרכז התקשורת החב״די - סיפורו של הרב שעמד בראש הלוחמים נגד אנשי שבתאי צבי - חב״ד און ליין, col.org.il/news/133519
- 6.Tzvi Hirsch Ben Yaakov ASHKENAZI : Family tree by Gordon ASHBURY (gordonashbury) - Geneanet, gw.geneanet.org/gordonashbury?lang=en&n=ashkenazi&p=tzvi+hirsch+ben+yaakov
- 7.Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi - Chacham Tzvi — yahrzeit 1 Iyar, silatehilim.com/en/events/1-ияра-йорцайт-рабби-цви-гирш-ашкенази/
- 8.Rabbi Tzvi Ashkenazi (Chacham Tzvi) - (5418–5478; 1658–1718) - Chabad.org, chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/112072/jewish/Rabbi-Tzvi-Ashkenazi-Chacham-Tzvi.htm
- 9.רבי צבי הירש אשכנזי ה"חכם צבי" זצ"ל - ר"ח אייר תע"ח - אידישע וועלט פארומס, ivelt.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7461
- 10.How Rabbi Tzvi Hersh Ashkenazi (the Chacham Tzvi) defended the view of Rabbi David Nieto in London in the 18th century - Oxford Chabad Society, oxfordchabad.org/templates/blog/post_cdo/aid/708481/PostID/116095
- 11.שיחת השבוע 944 | בא הרוג ברגליו - צעירי אגודת חב"ד, chabad.org.il/Magazines/Article.asp?ArticleID=1718&CategoryID=605
- 12.חכם צבי | האוסף של ספריא, sefaria.org.il/Chakham_Tzvi
- 13.אשכנזי, צבי הירש בן יעקב (חכם צבי) 1658-1718 (page 73 of 158) - HebrewBooks, hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=829&pgnum=73
- 14.רבי יעקב ב"ר צבי עמדין המכונה יעב"ץ - פורום לתורה, tora-forum.co.il/threads/רבי-יעקב-ב-ר-צבי-עמדין-המכונה-יעב-ץ.42695/
- 15.שולחן ערוך אורח חיים שב י - ויקיטקסט, he.wikisource.org/wiki/שולחן_ערוך_אורח_חיים_שב_י
- 16.Orach Chayyim 451 – אורח חיים תנא - Shulchan Arukh - ALHATORAH.ORG, shulchanarukh.alhatorah.org/Orach_Chayyim/451
- 17.דוד ניטו - ויקיפדיה, he.wikipedia.org/wiki/דוד_ניטו
- 18.פסק החכם צבי בעד רבי דוד ניטו - וסיומה של המחלוקת - כיכר השבת, kikar.co.il/haredim-news/rwt4v3
- 19.290 גליון מס' - ד"פשת י;quot&ח תמוז נמסר ביום ד' - בין המצרים ]א'[ תענית, פ, kolhalashon.com/PDF/Shiurim/38646/38646057_00693657.pdf
- 20.ו ברינה יקצור, files.cdn-files-a.com/uploads/11313289/normal_69b942a8ededc.pdf